Little Box of Horrors May 2021 | Supernatural

by Lisa Heath

Press Sample of Little Box of Horrors
May 2021 | Supernatural

Here we are – back for another Little Box of Horrors post! This time we’re looking at the Little Box Of Horrors May 2021 Box with a theme of Supernatural!

New to Little Box of Horrors? Well then, let’s explain it a bit:

This will be a bi-monthly collaboration shop that will consist of 25ish makers. Each bi-monthly shop will have either a horror, sci-fi, thriller, supernatural, paranormal, or mystery like theme – and the products will then be inspired by that theme.

This month the theme is Supernatural, and the makers brought their A-game for it. I am a fan of Supernatural, so I was happy to see this theme come up.

Little Box Of Horrors has set swatchers – however, makers are also able to send to their own swatchers as well. I will link the set swatchers at the end of this post.

Also when I say “set swatchers” makers aren’t forced to send to any of us, they can choose if they want to – so each of us have bits and pieces, but I think we’re all missing an item here and there. We also have a mix of bloggers, swatchers and live video to show.

Ready to jump on in and take a look?

All Mixed Up Lacquers | Tragic Circumstances

Inspiration: Inspired by Pilot Episode #1 The Lady in the White Dress (based on La Llorona)

Description: Tragic Circumstances is a white crelly base packed with gold and green shimmers, aurora shifting flakes, and a light sprinkling of black holo blend. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $11.00 | Cap: 50

Anchor & Heart Lacquer | Rascally Deity

Inspiration: Inspired by the deity who needs no introduction, notorious Daddy-O, Chuckles, and Chuck Shurly. The one, the only, God.

Description: Rascally Deity is a deep olive green crelly base that shifts with a strong gold to copper to pink shimmer and tiny copper micro glitter. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $12.50 | Cap: None

Anchor & Heart Lacquer | Tidal Mist Spray Lotion

Inspiration: The Winchester Boys

Description: Tidal Mist is a light, quick absorbing, spray-able lotion. For the Supernatural theme we have the scent Sexy as a Winchester – and it’s a blend of sandalwood, cinnamon, patchouli, amber and soft musk. Very genderless and it’s a fun, spicy scent.

After showering (or whenever you need lotion) spritz it all over and let it soak in (it doesn’t take long!) Makes it easy it you are in a hurry but need the hydration.

Price: $10.00 | Cap: 50

Apipila | Supernatural Stamping Plate

Inspiration: Supernatural

Description: I’ve seen Apipila come up with some incredible plates, but when this one arrived – I was majorly happy with it! This is a stainless steel stamping plate with a variety of Supernatural inspired images. From common phrases to general fan goodies and more.

The etching was nicely done on this plates. It’s a 10 x 15 cm sized plate

Price: $14.99 | Cap: 300

Apipila | Saving People Hunting Things (Stamping Polish)

Inspiration: Supernatural

Description: Apipila also has an incredibly pigmented black stamping polish for us! Simple staple for everyone’s stamping needs.

Price: $10.00 | Cap: 300

Baroness X | Fight The Fairies! (Magnetic)

Inspiration: Inspired by S6E9, the fairy attack.

Description: Fight the Fairies is a deeep olive, almost black base with gold to green magnetic and OGUP-like large particle shimmer that shifts red to bronze. I used 2 coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

I only magnetized the middle and ring finger so you can see it both ways.

Price: $12.50 | Cap: None

BCB Lacquers | Hey Ass-butt

Inspiration:Inspired by a Supernatural fan art poster.

Description: Hey Ass-butt is a magenta crelly based holo polish with pink to red to orange to gold shifting flakes, gun metal, white and gold flakes with red and orange shimmer. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $12.50 | Cap: 75

BCB Lacquers | Whipped Sugar Scrub


Description: A whipped sugar scrub with a custom oil blend for hydration and exfoliation! This mouthwatering boozy scent starts with top notes of apple, red currant, red wine, cinnamon, and a hint of orange. With bottom notes of sweet maple, spice and vanilla finish off this irresistible custom fragrance oil blend. This has white and brown sugar for extra exfoliation. On top you will see a sprinkle of gold beads and gold mica.

This smells like a cinnamon apple and it’s delicious. Fruity and spicy all at once. Plus the creamy scrub is great for exfoliation with some lathering.

Price: $11.50 | Cap: 20

Black Dahlia Lacquer | Calliope

Inspiration: Calliope in her purple dress in season 10.

Description: Calliope is a dark indigo crelly base with rainbow glitter in various sizes and blue to fuchsia to purple shifting flakes. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $11.50 | Cap: None

Dark Moon Esscentuals | Dirty B*tch Instant Facial

Inspiration: Dean’s use of the phrase always made me laugh-it’s also something that I heard my dad say a few times while fixing our cars!

Description: A hybrid of an exfoliating facial cleanser and a facial mask. This unique product is the answer to your skincare dreams!

To use I just wet my face, applied a small amount and massaged into my skin in small, circular motions. I let it sit for about 10 minutes, then I used a wash cloth to wash it off. Afterward, my skin was super soft and nicely exfoliated.

Price: $14.00 | Cap: 50

Esmaltes da Kelly | Brotherhood

Inspiration: Supernatural Poster

Description: Brotherhood is a blue jelly base with red to green shifting aurora shimmer.I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $12.50 | Cap: 100

Fanchromatic Nails | I Have A Little Hell To Raise (Glow In The Dark)

Inspiration: Inspired by Crowley, the King of Hell

Description: I Have A Little Hell to Raise is a soft coppery base that shifts to gold and reddish bronze, with metallic microflakes and microglitter, and larger chameleon flakes that shift red to gold to green, and it glows red in the dark! I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $12.00 | Cap: None

Inspira Designs | Supernatural Magnet

Inspiration: Anti-possession

Description: Resin anti-possession magnet! This is a nice, strong, resin magnet that matches the tattoo on the Winchester boys!

Price: $6.00 | Cap: 24

Jen & Berries | Take Me Home, Baby

Inspiration: a photo of Baby, Dean’s Impala, with a sunset backdrop

Description: Take Me Home, Baby is a black base with a deep mauve to gold shimmer, platinum flakes and holographic micro shreds. I used 2 coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $11.00 | Cap: 100

Jreine | The Guardian


Description: The Guardian is a deep purple jelly base loaded with copper to gold to green shimmer. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $13.00 | Cap: None

Lacquer Is In The Air | Bloody Mary, Bloody Mary, Bloody…

Inspiration: Bloody Mary episode

Description: Bloody Mary, Bloody Mary, Bloody… is a blackened red holo base with black to red multichrome pigment. I used 2 coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $13.00 | Cap: 200

LynBDesigns | Mmm… Pie Wax Melt


Description: Mmm…Pie is described as “aroma of freshly picked blueberries, fresh cut granny smith apples, smothered in butter, cream, and cinnamon, with a background of fresh baked crust.”

The blueberries are the prominent fruit note, but the granny smiths give it a bit of a tart kick. All mixed with fresh baked pie crush – it’s delicious.

Price: $4.50 | Cap: None

LynBDesigns | Please Accept This Sandwich (Magnetic)

Inspiration: Cas and sammiches

Description: Please Accept This Sandwich is a black base with blue magnetic pull, red to orange to yellow shifting crystal flakes, and holo micro glitters. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat.

I only magnetized 2 nails so you can see it both ways!

Price: $13.00 | Cap: None

MTK Designs | Eat Pie Kill Demons (Glow In The Dark)

Inspiration: Neon Sign highlighting Dean’s goals

Description: Eat Pie Kill Demons is a neon orange leaning red jelly base with intense blue to green shimmers with a glow in the dark effect. Now the glow is a whitish blue, however it distorts into a red due to the neon pigments and but with a whiting blue “backlighting” looking effect.

I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos. The GITD effect is a bit lighter in color than my photo of it shows.

Price: $12.00 | Cap: None

Nailed It Nail Polish | Walking On Sunshine

Inspiration: Charlie Bradbury

Description: Walking On Sunshine is a sheer, soft blue jelly base loaded with gold, red, copper and green crystal flakes. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

You should only need 1 coat of top coat for this polish, unless you do really thick coats and really pack those flakes on. Then you might need 2 coats for a smooth finish.

Price: $13.00 | Cap: 150

Paradox Polish | Eve Ain’t Gunna Gank Herself

Inspiration: Eve and Dean

Description: Eve Ain’t Gunna Gank Herself is a medium, slightly dusty, fuchsia tinged pink with ultrachrome chameleon flakes that shift from pink to gold to green, turquoise flakes, aurora shimmer and a touch of scattered holo. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $12.00 | Cap: None

Paradox Polish | Fire & Brimstone Shea Butter Cold Process Soap

Inspiration: Visiting Hell, escaping Hell or being the king of Hell

Description: Fire & Brimstone Shea Butter Cold Process Soap is a red and black soap with activated charcoal and shea butter based, and its scented in fire, brimstone… and a bit of bbq. It also has the anti possession symbol on top.

Scent wise it’s slightly… spicy? I think that’s the word I’m looking for, but it’s got that smokey, spicy thing going on. My son actually asked if he could have the soap when I was done because he liked the scent, but he prefers activated charcoal soaps/body washes. He breaks out easily (we both have combo leaning oily skin) and it helps keep the body acne at bay.

Soap has a good lather too. Feels super creamy and I quite like the scent.

Price: $8.00 | Cap: None

Peachtree Polish | Never Underestimate The King Of Hell (Thermal)

Inspiration: Crowley

Description: Never Underestimate the King of Hell is a thermal jelly base that shifts from a dusty reddish orange (cold) to bright sunny yellow (warm) with blue to green to gold ultrachrome chameleon flakes. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $12.00 | Cap: 50

Ribbits Stickits | Un-frog-gettable Hand & Cuticle Cream

Inspiration: Sam, Dean, and Castiel

Description: A trio of hand and cuticle creams in scents inspired by Sam, Dean and Castiel. Scent descriptions are as follows:

My People Skills Are Rusty: fresh air, crisp water, pineapple, oranges, coconut, grapefruit, green apple, pine, jasmine, apricot, vanilla, sandalwood, moss, lily, cedar, amber, musk, ocean breeze. This is a bright, fruity and floral scent. It’s on the lighter scent but still smells… clean.

I Lost My Shoe: leafy greens, herbs, birch leaves, lemon, clementine, jasmine, ozone, vetiver, sandalwood, cedar, coriander, tobacco, tonka bean, vanilla, and amber. This has that nice musk from jasmine while being a little spicy and smooth. It’s an interesting blend that I wasn’t sure about at first, but then I fell in love with it.

I Love Me Some Pie: Macintosh apples, cinnamon, clove, green leaves, almond, pie crust, vanilla, bourbon, caramel. Cinnamon apple pie. DELICIOUS!

Price: $10.00 | Cap: 40

Ribbits Stickits | Waterslide Decals

Inspiration: Supernatural

Description: Waterslide decals are best compared to temporary tattoos with a slight difference (other than it being on your nails vs skin). You still wet the back, but then you slide the image off the paper backing and place on the nail.

Ribbits Stickits brings us 3 sheets of Supernatural inspired waterslide decals!

Cut out the design you want, place in warm water for about 10-15 seconds, lift and then slide the image off and place on the nail. Pat dry and remove air bubbles – then top coat to seal it in.

Price: $15.00 | Cap: 50

Saki Cosmetics | That Was Scary! (Magnetic)


Description: That Was Scary! Is a navy polish with gold to pink magnetic pigment. The magnetic effect is more on the subtle side, but still noticeable in person. I used 3 thin coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $12.50 | Cap: 50

Sassy Pants Polish | Cuticle Balm

Inspiration: Rowena

Description: This luxurious and moisturizing cuticle balm is enriched with all natural skin-loving ingredients and smells like a tea rose with a mysterious nuance of green and powder. Label also includes a computer rendered photo of Rowena.

This has a nice, lightly floral and herbal like scent. It’s soothing!

Price: $6.50 | Cap: 50

The Soapy Chef | Resin Phone Grip


Description: This is a black scattered holographic resin phone grip with silver holo lettering, that has an adhesive backing to easily attach to your phone. Push it in when not needed, and pull it out (or “pop” it out) and it can act as a finger grip or you can use it to prop your phone up.

Price: $9.00 | Cap: 75

The Soapy Chef | Solid Lotion Bar

Inspiration: Sam and Dean’s need to have everything road ready.

Description: This solid lotion bar will help moisturize dry areas without greasiness or stickiness. It looks like a bar of soap at first glance, but when you pick it up, your body heat melts the lotion on contact so you can smooth it into your skin.

Scent nodes: Blood orange, tangerine, cassis, chilli pepper, negroni, orange juice

I love the citrus kick, but also that touch of chili pepper!

Price: $7.50 | Cap: 70

Treo Lacquer | I Like Past You

Inspiration: inspired by Castiel in The End.

Description: I Like Past You is a blackened shimmery olive creme base with blue flecks that kind of glow against the deep backdrop. I used 2 coats and a glossy top coat for these photos.

Price: $12.00 | Cap: 80

Little Box of Horrors May 2021 | Supernatural

What a fun box this month and a great assortment of items! I cannot wait to see what’s to come in July.

Tiana of Nailed It In AZ
Cheyenne of CBDNails
Nina of Keen_Neens_Nails
Jailyn of Jailyn.nailart
La Tannya will be doing a live swatch in the FB group (group link below!)

Where to Buy: Little Box of Horrors Shop

Preorder Dates: May 18th – May 30th

Little Box of Horrors Social Media: Facebook Fan Group | Instagram

Hope you enjoyed, and be sure to check out all the swatchers involved, plus join the group to see even more swatches!

You may also like

1 comment

Erin August 30, 2021 - 6:35 am

How do we buy the Supernatural nail stamp plate? T__T


Leave a Comment